Miami Referendum 3: Public Waterfront Should Not Be Sold Short

Vote no on Miami referendum 3 poster on display at the Rickenbacker Marina & Boatyard along the Rickenbacker Causeway in Miami, Florida, on Tuesday, October 6, 2026. Miami voters will decide whether to lease about 27.6 acres of publicly owned waterfront on Virginia Key to a private developer for up to 75 years.

A 75-year lease based on financial terms negotiated nearly a decade ago raises serious questions about accountability, fairness and the future of Miami’s valuable public waterfront.

Miami’s waterfront is among its most valuable public assets. Once its future is committed for generations, taxpayers may have little opportunity to reconsider the decision.

That is why Miami voters should reject Referendum 3.

The measure would authorize a 75-year lease involving more than 27 acres of public waterfront property on historic Virginia Key, under financial terms negotiated in 2017.

For a city confronting rising housing costs, infrastructure challenges and growing demands for public services, the central question is straightforward: Why should taxpayers accept yesterday’s financial terms for tomorrow’s public assets?

Aabad Melwani, co-founder of Preserve & Protect Miami, argues that residents deserve a better agreement.

“Miami Referendum 3 — on the last page of the City of Miami ballot — would lock the City into a 75-year lease of over 27 acres of valuable public waterfront on Historic Virginia Key, under financial terms negotiated back in 2017. That waterfront belongs to Miami taxpayers. Miami deserves a deal that reflects today’s current value — one that brings more money into the City to fund public services and improvements that residents actually benefit from. We shouldn’t be giving away public land to out-of-state developers at our taxpayers’ expense. The City currently earns more money from that property than what the developer is ‘guaranteeing.’”

Melwani offers a comparison that voters can understand.

“I often ask folks, ‘Would you rent your house out for 2017 rent?’ The answer of course is ‘NO’. Are any of us paying 2017 prices for rent, gas, groceries, and insurance? ‘NO’. So why should an out-of-state, private equity-backed developer get a discount on public land based on prices from nearly a decade ago? That’s why we’re urging Miami voters to VOTE NO #291 on Miami Referendum 3.”

The argument deserves serious consideration.

Miami’s real estate market has changed dramatically since 2017. Property values, development opportunities and the cost of maintaining public infrastructure have increased.

Taxpayers should reasonably expect the city to negotiate agreements reflecting present economic conditions.

Supporters may argue that long-term leases encourage investment, economic development and improvements to underused property. Those benefits deserve consideration.

But economic development should not come at the expense of responsible stewardship of public land.

Before committing waterfront property for 75 years, Miami should provide an independent appraisal, transparent financial projections and a clear accounting of the benefits residents would receive.

The public also deserves assurances that environmental protections, waterfront access and the historic character of Virginia Key will remain priorities.

A 75-year commitment could affect generations of Miami residents who will have no opportunity to vote on its original terms.

Rejecting Referendum 3 does not mean rejecting development. It means demanding a better agreement.

Miami’s waterfront belongs to the public. Its value should benefit the public.

Vote NO on Referendum 3. Miami deserves a fair deal, not a 75-year commitment to yesterday’s prices.

Author

Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *